Case Studies

How Cultural Fluency Built Trust and Grew Share in a Commoditized Category

People working out

The Challenge

A prominent Health & Wellness brand found itself in a saturated market where product functionality had become table stakes and consumer trust was elusive. Despite strong brand awareness, shoppers viewed its offering as interchangeable with lower-cost alternatives, limiting both loyalty and premium pricing potential. The brand needed to break out of the transactional mold and forge emotional connections, particularly among younger and multicultural consumers who were driving the category’s growth.

The Approach

The brand partnered with Collage to assess its standing through the Brand Cultural Fluency Quotient (B-CFQ) across diverse consumer segments. Results revealed that while Trust and Product Fit were on par with competitors, Relevance, Memories, and Advocacy were trailing – indicators that the brand was not meaningfully resonating with culture or integrating into consumers’ lives in moments that mattered most.

To close these cultural gaps, Collage Group guided the brand through an insight-to-execution journey grounded in consumer passion points, social and cultural trends, and everyday health rituals:

Relevance

Insights highlighted opportunities to tap into self-care moments rooted in indulgence and fitness. For example, Gen Z and Millennials were significantly more likely to indulge in less health eating & drinking behaviors after high-intensity workouts.

Memories and values

Social content analysis uncovered that consumers often consumed products in this category in real, unscripted moments during travel or what’s in my gym bag – but they chose the unhealthy alternatives. These occasions presented the brand with an opportunity to become part of consumers’ everyday routines and positive rituals.

Trust and Advocacy

Collage encouraged the brand to embrace creator partnerships that featured raw, relatable stories – like young women candidly discussing their feelings after indulgences and the difference in physical and emotional comfort when they chose healthier alternatives. These narratives built on existing strong trust and resonated deeply, especially among multicultural segments.

The Solution

  1. Co-created content with lifestyle and wellness influencers across platforms like TikTok and Instagram, amplifying real-life moments of use.
  2. Launched creative that acknowledged the real trade-off of rewarding oneself with indulgences after healthy workouts or dieting – making the brand feel human.
  3. Tied product usage to moments of celebration and self-expression – like holiday overindulgence, and post-workout rituals – to increase perceived Fit and Relevance with younger, culture-forward audiences.
  4. Positioned the product as a vital companion in self-care routines, particularly for women and Gen Z, emphasizing empowerment and control over their bodies.

The Business Impact

In just one year, the brand saw measurable growth in cultural relevance and brand love:

  • Advocacy scores increased across key segments, with especially strong gains among Gen Z and Hispanic consumers, who appreciated the product’s integration into social content and daily rituals.
  • Relevance and Memories showed double-digit lifts in B-CFQ scores, thanks to successful creative that reflected multicultural experiences, food and wellness, and lifestyle trends.
  • Sales outpaced category growth during key promotional windows, including holiday campaigns, as the brand capitalized on consumer-driven trade-off moments.

By embedding itself in the real, unscripted moments that define consumers’ lives, this Health & Wellness brand transcended its commoditized positioning. It built emotional bonds rooted in cultural fluency, unlocking a pathway to brand differentiation, trust, and long-term growth.